When trust distributions to a company are left unpaid
Aspen Corp • 7 November 2023

What happens when a trust appoints income to a private company beneficiary but does not actually make the payment?


The tax treatment of this unpaid amount was at the centre of a recent case before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) that saw a taxpayer successfully challenge the ATO’s long held position (Bendel and Commissioner of Taxation [2023] AATA 3074). For many years, the ATO’s position has been that if a trust appoints income to a private company beneficiary but does not actually make the payment, this unpaid amount can be treated as a loan. Under Division 7A of the tax rules, these loans can be taxed as unfranked dividends unless they are managed using a complying loan agreement with annual principal and interest repayments.


This AAT decision challenges an important ATO position, with the tax outcomes being potentially significant for trust clients that currently owe (or may have owed in the past) unpaid trust entitlements to related private companies.


But this is not the end of this story. On 26 October 2023, the Tax Commissioner lodged a notice of appeal to the Federal Court. There is no guarantee that the Federal Court will reach the same conclusion as the AAT. We will need to wait and see.


As the case progresses, we will let you know about the impact.


For further information about trust distrubtions check out other Aspen Corp blog posts

 

https://www.aspencorp.com.au/the-atos-final-position-on-risky-trust-distributions

 

https://www.aspencorp.com.au/the-atos-attack-on-trusts-and-trust-distributions

 

https://www.aspencorp.com.au/ato-fires-warning-shot-on-trust-distributions

Cyber In Accounting: Safeguarding Financial Data in a Digital Age

Cyber In Accounting: Safeguarding Financial Data in a Digital Age

by Aspen Corp • 6 November 2025
Many businesses hold critical data that poses significant risk to businesses and their customers if the data they hold is not safeguarded from cybersecurity threats.
Proposed Extension of the Instant Asset Write-Off and Other Tax Measures

Proposed Extension of the Instant Asset Write-Off and Other Tax Measures

by Aspen Corp • 6 November 2025
A new Bill before Parliament – the Treasury Laws Amendment Bill 2025 – proposes changes that could affect small businesses, listed companies, and not-for-profits.
Imagine this: after years of hardship and illness, you’re forced to retire early on a Total and Perm

When Medical Bills Meet Tax Rules – Lessons from a Heartbreaking Case

by Aspen Corp • 4 November 2025
In Wannberg v Commissioner of Taxation , the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) upheld the ATO’s decision to deny nearly $100,000 in medical deductions.
Super Tax Shake-Up: Big Balances Beware

Super Tax Shake-Up: Big Balances Beware

by Aspen Corp • 3 November 2025
But if your super is nudging that level, or if you’re clearly over, the Treasurer’s latest announcement could change how you think about super’s generous tax breaks.

Accessing superannuation funds for medical treatment or financial hardship

by Aspen Corp • 2 October 2025
Accessing superannuation funds for medical treatment or financial hardship
Government Review of Supermarket Unit Pricing: What It Could Mean for Your Business

Government Review of Supermarket Unit Pricing: What It Could Mean for Your Business

by Aspen Corp • 2 October 2025
The Federal Government had a consultation process on supermarket unit pricing. This is not only a consumer issue, but it could have commercial impacts for suppliers
More posts