Aspen Corporate Pty Ltd
The case of the taxpayer who was paid too late
Aspen Corp • 5 September 2023

The case of the taxpayer who was paid too late

What a difference timing makes. A recent case before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) is a reminder about the tax impact of the timing of employment income. 


In this case, the taxpayer was a non-resident working in Kuwait. As part of his work, he was entitled to a ‘milestone bonus’ but, the employer was not in a position to pay the bonus at the time.


When the job ended, the taxpayer moved to Australia and became a resident. Once in Australia, the former employer honoured the performance bonus and paid it as a series of instalments.


The dispute between the ATO and the taxpayer started when the Commissioner issued amended assessments taxing the bonus payments received.


The dispute focused on when the bonus was derived. Had the bonus been derived while the taxpayer was still a non-resident then it would not have been taxed in Australia. This is because non-residents are normally only taxed in Australia on Australian sourced income. Employment income is typically sourced in the place where the work is performed (although there can be exceptions to this).


Australian tax case law says that employment income is normally derived on receipt. In the taxpayer’s case, this was when he received the payments from his former employer, not when he became entitled to the bonus. Because the taxpayer received the bonus when he was a tax resident of Australia, the bonus was subject to tax.


The difference for the taxpayer was quite dramatic. Had he been paid the bonus when it was due, he would have paid no tax as Kuwait does not impose income tax.


Please call us if you are concerned about tax residency or managing overseas income. 

by Aspen Corp 26 March 2025
Aspen Corp's 2025-26 Federal Budget Update
Australian girl holding a flag
by Aspen Corp 19 March 2025
Global Google searches for the word “tariffs” spiked dramatically between 30 January and 2 February 2025, a +900% increase to the previous 12 months. We look at what tariffs really mean.
by Domenic Tartaglia 19 March 2025
The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) continues it's focus on proper record-keeping practices for Next 5,000 privately owned and wealthy groups, emphasizing the need for transparency and accuracy in tax reporting.
by Aspen Corp 11 March 2025
The Fringe Benefits Tax (FBT) year ends on 31 March. We’ve outlined the hot spots for employers and employees.
Australian suburban property
by Aspen Corp 11 March 2025
The Government has announced a ban on foreign property purchases until 31 March 2027 to curb foreign “land banking.”
Credit Cards
by Aspen Corp 13 February 2025
If credit card surcharges are banned in other countries, why not Australia? We look at the surcharge debate and the payment system complexity that has brought us to this point.
More posts
Share by: